Donate

2nd April 2005

Letter to The Spectator

Sir,

The piece by Rod Liddle contains the erroneous use of the terms “illegal” and “bogus” for asylum seekers. Asylum seekers are individuals exercising their legal right to claim asylum and may have fled acts of horrendous violence including torture, persecution and even genocide; they are legally in the UK while their claims are considered.

The number of asylum claims in industrialised countries is plummeting, with arrivals in the UK down 61 percent since 2002 to levels not seen since the mid-1990s. It is simply not possible to claim that there is an asylum crisis, nor is there ever a need for writers like Mr. Liddle to denigrate those people who may be forced to seek asylum.

The UN refugee agency encourages debate on immigration issues, but we are disappointed when informed minds such as your columnists confuse illegal immigrants for asylum seekers. Such disinformation helps to create a negative image amongst the people towards people seeking protection, sowing mistrust. Illegal immigrants are those who have (i) entered the UK illegally, without permission from an Immigration Officer, who then continue to reside in the UK without contacting the authorities or making an asylum claim; or (ii) entered the country legally, with all the necessary documents, but then disregard limits placed on the length of their stay.

We believe clarifying these terms will clear up the sometimes cloudy debate on immigration.

Sincerely,

Anne Dawson-Shepherd
Representative



Copyright 2003 UNHCR in the UK. All Rights Reserved.
Developed by Intronet